Connect with us


How should cryptocurrency be taxed in India? Here are some thoughts



Warren Buffet, the greatest investor of all time, once scrapped bitcoins and actually called them “rat poison squared.” Not many investors take this advice to heart, however; Cryptocurrencies have attracted a lot of interest from investors of all ages due to their recent appreciation. It is estimated that around one million Indians have invested in cryptocurrencies, reports suggest.

Are profits from cryptocurrencies taxable?

Tax authorities around the world have worked to develop tax rules for cryptocurrencies. Even if cryptocurrencies are not mentioned in the Indian Income Tax Act and no rules have yet been defined, you must report them and pay tax on your income tax return.

An asset or a currency?

When we talk about taxes, many questions arise. Should cryptocurrencies be viewed as a currency or a digital good? If viewed as an asset, how long should these assets be held for in order for them to be classified as long-term or short-term investments? Since cryptocurrencies are not yet as widespread as other currencies, they are now viewed as “digital assets” in several countries. Note that India does not currently have a rule to tax these cryptocurrencies.

Should they be treated as an investment in India?

Countries like the UK and the US have stipulated that cryptocurrencies should be treated like investments. The definition of capital assets in Indian Income Tax Law is broader and therefore includes assets that may not be defined separately. Such assets can be treated as long-term assets if they are held for more than three years and as current assets if they are held for less than three years. It can make sense to allow an indexation of 20% for the acquisition costs. Regarding the tax rate, we can tax them at a rate of 20% (additional duties and surcharges if applicable). Short-term capital gains can be taxed at the flat rates applicable to the taxpayer. Note that no specific guidelines for taxing crypto assets are yet available under the Income Tax Act.

Can more crypto trading be classified as a business activity?

If a taxpayer has a significant transaction volume and does not intend to hold these assets for a longer period of time, the question arises whether such an activity is to be regarded as a business. This has to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Viewing crypto trading as a business activity involves reporting and claiming expenses associated with such activity. If the turnover exceeds a certain threshold, doubts about the applicability of the GST can arise. Some of these questions are not yet addressed by the tax authorities. Another aspect to be clarified is whether a loss from the sale of crypto assets can be offset or carried forward.

What should i do?

First, you need to make sure that you are keeping proper records of all of your transactions. Second, always keep in mind that these assets are unregulated in India and therefore there is a high potential risk of owning or trading them. However, you will have to pay tax once you have earned an income. Seek the help of an expert who can guide you through this. If you’re a miner, you may have created an asset that you created yourself. Miners also invest a lot of time and money building these assets, and so taxation can be an entirely different game in their case.

Archit Gupta is the founder and CEO of ClearTax. Views are his own.

Dear Reader,

Business Standard has always endeavored to provide updated information and commentary on developments that are of interest to you and that have far-reaching political and economic implications for the country and the world. Your encouragement and constant feedback to improve our offering has only strengthened our determination and commitment to these ideals. Even in these troubled times resulting from Covid-19, we continue to strive to keep you updated with credible news, authoritative views, and apt comments on current topics.
However, we have a request.

In the fight against the economic effects of the pandemic, we need your support even more so that we can continue to offer you high-quality content. Our subscription model has had an encouraging response from many of you who have subscribed to our online content. More subscriptions to our online content can only help us achieve our goals of offering you even better and more relevant content. We believe in free, fair and credible journalism. Your support through more subscriptions can help us practice the journalism to which we are dedicated.

Support quality journalism and Subscribe to Business Standard.

Digital editor

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Cryptocurrency: Here’s How the Top 5 Coins Have Performed Since April 2021



Cryptocurrencies have got off to a slow start this year, largely due to an order from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to banks telling them not to trade crypto. Cryptocurrency trading accelerated after the Supreme Court lifted the RBI ban in March and allowed coins such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, Dogecoin, and others to be traded. Since then, several online exchanges such as CoinSwitch Kuber and CoinDCX have flourished. But investing in these virtual assets requires due diligence given the extreme volatility of most cryptocurrencies. One way to do this is to look at the historical dates of these coins.

How cryptocurrencies have behaved in the past few weeks and months can give an idea of ​​their potential in the near future and whether a person should invest now or wait.

This is how the top 5 digital coins have behaved since the beginning of this financial year (as of April 1):


Bitcoin is the oldest cryptocurrency in the world. Since its introduction in 2009, it has remained an undisputed leader in the cryptocurrency market. It was Rs. 42 lakh on April 1st of that year, but by the end of May, when the market collapsed massively due to a Chinese crackdown on mining, it had hit a low of Rs. 22 lakh. However, Bitcoin has recovered. On September 17th it was Rs. 37 lakhs.


Experts say this is the only virtual currency that has a chance to challenge Bitcoin’s dominance, but it is far from realizing its true potential. At the beginning of this fiscal year, Ethereum was trading at Rs. 1.40 lakh. It broke the Rs. 2 lakh barrier by early August. This was the time when the Ethereum blockchain had the big London upgrade. Since then, it has grown in value continuously. As of September 17, at the time of writing, it was Rs. 2.76 lakhs.


Launched in 2017, Cardano is a relatively new cryptocurrency coin that has skipped the line to find its place in the top 5. Billed as a third-generation blockchain (Bitcoin and Ethereum are the first and second generation, respectively), Cardano achieved a return of almost 150 percent in just one month. On July 20, it was trading at Rs. 79.71 but by August it had peaked at Rs. 191.41. It saw further gains over the next few weeks, hitting an all-time high of Rs. 227 earlier this month. But profits have since started to decline. On September 17, at the time of writing, it was Rs. 187.82.


Tether is a stablecoin pegged to the US dollar. As the first coin, it is the most popular stablecoin. Since it is pegged to the dollar, meaning that each Tether coin should be backed by actual dollars in Tether Limited’s reserves, it is very stable compared to other cryptocurrencies. If this stability is predictable, it also limits the ability to grow wealth quickly. It stayed within the Rs. 73–75 this fiscal year. It was about Rs. 77 on 09/17.


It is the fifth ranked cryptocurrency in terms of market capitalization. Technically, Ripple is not a cryptocurrency. It facilitates open source payments and XRP is the cryptocurrency that runs on this network. The price has doubled from Rs since April 1st. 41 to Rs. 80 now. But it hasn’t seen a rally similar to what it did in late 2017, which hit its all-time high of Rs 242 in early January 2018. At the time of writing, it was Rs. 84.

Interested in cryptocurrency? We discuss everything about crypto with WazirX CEO Nischal Shetty and WeekendInvesting founder Alok Jain on Orbital, the Gadgets 360 podcast. Orbital is available on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and anywhere you get your podcasts.

Continue Reading


financial: Cryptocurrency Hyper Fund under government scanner



NEW DELHI: The government is closely monitoring the cryptocurrency in the market based outside of the country after alerting that the authorities responsible for investigating financial fraud are watching a company called Hyper Fund.

Sources said Hyper Fund, a DEFI from the Hyper Tech Group, recently got under the radar. The group claims to have launched the Hyperfonds to provide a decentralized financial infrastructure. Hyper Fund was announced in mid-2020.

However, according to the company’s website, it is run by Ryan Xu, however, using the Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) model, Hyper Fund has attracted investors with higher returns and such offers, a common practice with Ponzi programs that have alerted authorities first place.

According to sources, complaints against such funds are piling up in several states. In India, the RBI, the Union Finance Ministry and SEBI had warned against trading in cryptocurrencies. The RBI plans to launch India’s official digital currency – E rupee – shortly.

The Treasury Department has made it clear that virtual currencies are not legal tender either. Therefore, VCs are not currencies. The RBI has also made it clear that it has not granted any company / company a license / authorization to operate or trade in Bitcoin or a virtual currency.

In June 2018, Amit Bhardwaj and his brother Vivek Bhardwaj were arrested by Pune police at Delhi Airport in connection with an alleged pyramid scheme. Bhardwaj, started his own Bitcoin mining operation and reportedly defrauded more than 8,000 people across the country for Rs 2,000 crore.

He has filed a complaint with the Delhi Police Department’s special cell alleging that he received a blackmail call and was asked to pay protection money on September 6, 2021 in exchange for promised higher returns.

UK regulators have issued warnings about such funds, and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has issued warnings for both hyper-funds and fund advisers.

On its website, first published March 23, 2021 and later updated on August 31, the FCA said, “We believe this company may offer, advertise or sell financial services or products in the UK without our approval Any financial service or product required in the UK must be authorized or registered by us. This company is not authorized by us and is aimed at individuals in the UK. ”

She warns investors against such a fund and goes on to say, “You do not have access to the Financial Ombudsman Service or are protected by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS), so you are unlikely to get your money back if something goes wrong . ”

The website used by these companies under the FCA is,

Decentralized finance offering (DEFI) via blockchain technology from HyperTech Group, which is said to be based in Hong Kong, sources said Indian regulators and agencies have started monitoring the situation.

Following actions by financial regulators such as the US Security and Exchange Commission and the UK Financial Conduct Authority, Indian regulators and enforcement agencies have started overseeing investments in Hyper Fund – a decentralized financial offering powered by blockchain technology from the HyperTech Group.

Financial regulators around the world recognize the fact that Ponzi program organizers often use the latest innovations, technologies, products, or growth industries to attract investors and promise high returns on their program. Potential investors are often less skeptical of an investment opportunity when they judge something new, new or “current”. On its website, Hyper Fund claims to be “the strongest rocket in blockchain funding”.

Continue Reading


A Lawyer Beginner’s Guide to Cryptocurrency Exchange



A cryptocurrency exchange is a platform that enables users to trade different currencies and Cryptocurrency Types.

A crypto exchange has an interface similar to that of a bank or investment firm, but differs in a few notable ways. The exchange acts as a central platform that connects buyers and sellers of various cryptocurrencies. Its main value is that it provides near-instant liquidity around the clock for many cryptocurrency asset pairs.

Popular exchanges like Coinbase and Gemini hold billions of dollars in cryptocurrencies, some of which are owned directly by the company and some by users who use it Exchange’s cryptocurrency wallet.

There are some notable differences in the field of cryptocurrency exchanges that we will go into in detail.

  1. Is the cryptocurrency exchange centralized or is it completely decentralized?
  2. Is the exchange safe or not?

Here’s what every lawyer, and frankly everyone who interacts with the financial world, should know why choosing the right cryptocurrency exchange makes all the difference.

Is the cryptocurrency exchange centralized or is it completely decentralized?

As you may have learned from reading The Legal Examiner The Blockchain: A Guide for Lawyers Series, cryptocurrency like Bitcoin is completely decentralized.

This means that there is no central company or entity responsible for Bitcoin – there is no fancy San Francisco tech startup office or a 1-800 number to dial if things get mixed up.

This is in contrast to a centralized exchange, which is a formally established entity that must adhere to guidelines and regulations. Of course there are fraudulent centralized exchanges that do not conform to the “formally established” definition, per se, but the point remains valid.

A centralized exchange, such as Coinbase or many of its direct alternatives, has chiseled its value proposition to make cryptocurrencies much more accessible to the average person.

Instead of two individuals agreeing to send each other different currencies (e.g. BTC for ETH), a central exchange handles the transaction and takes a small cut. This fee, often referred to as the maker-taker fee, gives the centralized exchange (or liquidity provider as we will learn below) an incentive to participate in the market. Makers are the market makers who create the bilateral markets (the exchange) and the takers are those who trade at the prices set by the market makers.

If you’re curious about how much money an exchange like Coinbase can make with these relatively low fees, take a look at these S-1 statement It was released before it went public in 2021.

Now imagine taking centralized exchange out of the equation. With no intermediary, the trading parties would be responsible for setting the prices at which they would be willing to trade the assets and trusting that the other party would send their fair share of the transaction.

As you can imagine, without a structure, this is an incredibly inefficient and untrustworthy way to trade digital assets on a large scale.

This is where decentralized exchanges (DEX) come into play.

A DEX is basically a decentralized platform that allows users to trade directly and instantly through preprogrammed contracts. The DEX forwards the order and only completes it when both parties have signed the transaction and the blockchain validates the entire ordeal.

Companies like Shapeshifting and MetaMask allow users to instantly trade their funds with one another without ever giving intermediate custody of their assets.

How do DEXs make money? They sometimes charge fees (not to be confused with the actual blockchain network fees that are incurred on every transaction, centralized or not) that can be distributed to the token holders of that exchange’s token.

the DEX model gets a little hairy, but it’s a fascinating journey to experience, especially as it serves as a portal into the world of decentralized finance (DeFi).

Is the exchange safe or not?

As mentioned in the previous section, centralized exchanges (CEXs) differ from decentralized exchanges (DEXs) in that they hold user assets while DEXs do not.

To be technically more precise, the CEXs keep your private keys, as they are not actual ones “Coins” or “Tokens” exist somewhere in a vault. A DEX allows you to trade without revealing your private key to the DEX or the receiving party.

Custody exchanges pose a significant risk. For one, your private keys are at risk if the exchange is hacked or exposed as an elusive fraud.

Hacking Mt. Gox, a popular early exchange, posed an existential threat to the burgeoning bitcoin. In February 2014, hackers stole a whopping 840,000 bitcoins from Mt. Gox customers and the company itself, with only 100,000 owned by the company – which is today equates to about $ 33.6 billion.

Other notable centralized exchange hacks and glitches include: Bithumb ($ 30 million), Coinrail ($ 37.2 million), BitGrail ($ 195 million), Coincheck ($ 534 million) – each value being set in the period in which it was was hacked.

Hopefully, while today’s exchanges have learned from the mistakes of the past, the threat remains. These exchanges use a combination of Warm and cold storage to make sure a Mt Gox disaster doesn’t happen again.

When you use a DEX, you are the greatest threat for your money. Since you are keeping your assets safe at all times, you are the primary point of potential failure. If you lose your device and cannot recover your account, or if someone targets your wallet directly, you could lose your money indefinitely.

However, these events can be avoided almost entirely with proper digital safety hygiene.

Final Thoughts: How to Pick the Right Crypto Exchange for You

Your choice of cryptocurrency exchanges ultimately depends on convenience, assuming you choose from a handful of vetted and reputable companies.

If you fall into the absolute beginner archetype of cryptocurrency, it’s worth creating a Coinbase account and trying the beginner-friendly platform. It lacks much of the advanced trading functionality, but it does achieve what you’re looking for: buying your first bitcoin, ether, or any other cryptocurrency.

Coinbase Learn also gives you some options to find out about specific cryptocurrency projects and earn a small fraction of their tokens.

If you choose to buy cryptocurrencies on Coinbase, you will likely soon outgrow the comparatively high fees – they’re nothing to sleep on, but they add up and there are cheaper options.

The good news is that you don’t have to leave the Coinbase ecosystem to avoid the high fees. Coinbase Pro is the “Pro” version of Coinbase and belongs to the same company. Not only does it have much lower fees across the board, but it also has a lot more investment pairs and the ability to deposit and buy crypto directly with USD.

Other Coinbase alternatives are: Twins, octopus, and BlockFi.

However, each of the options listed above is a custody platform, which means that they will keep your private keys in their own cryptocurrency wallet. This removes (albeit abandoned) the responsibility of maintaining your private keys, which makes it a lot easier for a beginner in the ecosystem.

For those who are in line with the “Be Your Own Bank” ethos of cryptocurrency, consider a non-custodial exchange platform like ShapeShift, MyEtherWallet, or Metamask. You will still keep your private keys in custody, but you can trade for other assets and likely pay much lower fees than on a central exchange.

Platforms without custody usually also facilitate the connection to the world of decentralized finance (DeFi). However, if you’re just getting started, we don’t recommend jumping in here just yet!

Continue Reading